I don't see what possible debate there can be. The rules for spawn say 1-2 can be taken as a single rare choice. The rules for Scyla explicitly state he IS a chaos spawn, and tells us he follows all rules for spawn except those explicitly exempted. This is EXACTLY as it is written.ġ) The unity entry for Scyla says "Chaos Spawn (see above but may not be marked)".Ģ) The unity entry for chaos spawn says "1-2 chaos spawn may be taken as a single rare choice". It's still not solid enough to try and pull on someone unless they agree beforehand IMO. The discussion isn't really helped that most people who disagree with Scyla included in the 2-4-1 deal ignore the "Scyla follows the rules for Chaos Spawn (see above)" part of things. This is a "maybe it works like that, who knows?" kind of thing. One of the rules for spawn say he can be taken 2 for 1 on a rare choice.Īs such, by RAW, yes, you can take him and another spawn for one rare choice because the MoC book explicitly states that he follows all the rules for spawn (except for the specifically articulated exception), and that is one of them. The rules say he follows the rules for spawn. It would appear that he thus follows the rules for spawns in every other regard, except for the one explicit exception. However it is the ONLY rule for spaws we are explicitly told to ignore when dealing with Scyla. It also explicitly states that he can not be marked, thus indicating that when we follow the rules for spawns, we ignore that rule. On the other hand is, one of Scyla's rules is that he is a spawn and as such, follows the rules for spawns. Scyla is a unique unit entry, and as such only follow the rules that apply TO HIM. Scyla is different from, say, Karanak who is explicitly an upgrade to a flesh hound and is not a unique unit entry. You know, I'm just not entirely convinced. Otherwise I am going to start putting rat ogres in my clan rat units like kroxigors since it doesn't say I can't. If it doesn't say you can in the book then that means you can not. Under regular spawn entry does it say you can also include scillia as part of a two spawn rare choice? Under Scillia's entry does it say you may include another spawn as a single rare choice? If you take that named flesh hound does it say you can take more flesh hounds in the same army book entry? If you take that named flesh hound can you still take more flesh hounds?
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |